Despite the fact that Southern Illinois – and Carbondale in particular – has made great strides in the availability of better beer at some bars, restaurants and retailers over the last 18 months or so, there’s still an obvious and glaring absence of beer altogether in many businesses you’d otherwise expect to find it in the city. Packaged liquors – including beer – can only be found at a select few locations in Carbondale. Anyone else ever thought this fact was a little odd?
There’s a reason for it, though I’d be hard pressed to say it’s a good reason.
Grocery stores and gas stations, for example, are banned from selling packaged liquors. This decades-old ban has caused an interesting environment to develop for packaged liquor sales in the city. Only a handful of current retailers – seven to be exact – have been granted packaged liquor sales licenses. An eighth license was recently granted by the Carbondale city council, but the retailer has yet to open its location. If you couple the scarcity of retail liquor store licensures (compared to other cities of equal or even smaller size) with the total ban on grocery and gas stations package sales and you’ve effectively created a pretty exclusive fraternity, whether consciously or otherwise.
This fact cannot be overlooked and carries with it some pretty hefty implications.
A reporter for the region’s largest newspaper – The Southern Illinoisan – just wrote a story documenting the fact that the Carbondale city council is now starting to take another look at their longstanding packaged liquor sales ban and reconsidering whether it might actually be more of a detriment to the city’s growth and prosperity than it is a safeguard against some perceived abuse – which I can only assume was the reason to impose the ban in the first place how ever many years ago that was.
Now that’s a start. Hope and change I can believe in.
In the article penned by Blackwell Thomas, and appearing in the online edition of The Southern today, city councilman Joel Fritzler is quoted as saying “It's against free enterprise; it's against capitalism and it promotes monopolies …” I unashamedly agree with councilman Fritzler’s assessment on the current environment in the city. There seems to an unspoken atmosphere of favoritism going on within the city that gives some establishment owners a measure of an advantaged position that is hard to deny when viewed objectively. The extant ban helps keep this advantage in place and, further, serves to discourage new business ventures within the city. My words, not Councilman Fritzler's.
I don’t care to delve into the political motivations and machinations that have brought us to this point in Carbondale. All I’m really interested in is seeing the market open up to allow more businesses – like Schnuck’s, for example, who have stores as close as Cape Girardeau that boast an impressive selection of craft and specialty beer – have the chance to do the same here in Carbondale. Free enterprise works for beer too and it’s high time that this restrictive and regressive ban is lifted.We're finally getting better beer here in the shadow of the A-B InBev giant.
If you’re a local reader, and find yourself so inclined, I encourage you to make your voice heard when and where you can and encourage the Carbondale city council to continue to revisit this ban. Let me just say in closing that I do not advocate the abuse of alcohol in any way, shape or form. Those that know me know I am a strict moderationist. But I’m also a capitalist and this ban is not good for beer and it’s not good for business in Carbondale. It seems to me that if we focus our efforts on the responsible use of alcohol – even in a University town – we’ll achieve more than we would by continuing to suppress growth and restrict availability.This is not a willy-nilly plea to get more booze into more places in town, although I know it will be received that way by some.
For me, the real need for this kind of ban ended with the foregone era of “the Strip” in Carbondale. C’mon Council-people, Carbondale is not that town anymore. I think it's safe to say, too, that we're not going to regress into that town again anytime soon. Let’s free up these businesses who will responsibly sell packaged liquor within the city so we’re not driving them outside the city to spend their money. Call me crazy.
Please feel free to share your thoughts here, but I’d much rather you share them with any city council member directly. We may be closer now to lifting this ban than we’ve been in years.